DRE Voting Machines
8/10/07
Editor,
My thanks to Chronicle Staff Writer John Wildermuth for his 7/31/07 story Makers of voting machines battle critics over UC study. The idea of switching from paper to electronic ballots seems like a natural these days but it requires thoughtful consideration and design.
Steve Weir, Contra Costa County clerk, was mistaken when he described the state sponsored study mentioned in Wildermuth's piece as having "more to do with headlines than with definitive science or the pursuit of legitimate public policy". Worse was Sequoia Voting Systems spokesman Steven Bennett's ill-informed contention that such studies are not "real world scenario[s]".
I can't imagine any more self serving clap-trap.
I believe there is a place for regulated Direct Recorded Electronic (DRE) voting in the future of the nation and California but I support California Secretary Of State Debra Bowen's decision last Friday to decertify DRE voting machines with the "potential for serious security breaches".
John Arnzt, San Francisco Director of Elections, would do well to support Ms Bowen's ban. He should require The City to use DRE voting machines that run only Free Software whose code is available for public review. It would be worth both the wait and the effort because it is the right thing to do.
